Helpful tips for Lutherans shopping at a Catholic gift shop

catholic store

If you’re a Lutheran looking for liturgical, sacramental, historical Christian art, gifts, or devotional items, you’ve probably thought about checking out your local Catholic book and gift store. Goodness knows you’re not going to find much in the way of these things at your typical Protestant bookstore. In fact, there’s a chance that your church has used a Catholic supplier for some of its altar linens, vestments and other clergy attire, banners, communion ware, etc. The Catholic shop is going to be good for certain things, but it does require at least as much discernment as the other spot, so prepare to do some careful combing before you buy. Here are some pointers for lay shoppers…

  • Don’t bother with the books. This is true for Christian bookstores everywhere. Get books that you have vetted in advance; they often require special ordering. Not that there aren’t any books worth looking at– in fact, you can often find Arch books or other CPH supplies at various Christian stores– but for the most part, you just don’t know what you’re going to get, and odds are that there will be theological concerns.
  • Themes and things that Catholic gift stores have that are hard to go wrong with: Advent wreaths and candles, Good Shepherd themed pictures and statues, ordinary crucifixes for the wall or to wear, reproductions of biblical scenes and themes from the old masters, nativity scene supplies. These things are probably a big part of the reason you want to check out the Catholic spot in the first place. Like all Christian book and gift stores, you’ll find your fair share of kitsch, but you’re much more likely to find things that reflect the liturgical beauty of historical Christendom at the Catholic bookstore.


  • Now, for the things to be careful about. We’ll start with the Christmas cards. Christmas cards are generally much more beautiful, even more biblically representative, that what you’ll find at an evangelical bookstore. But look closely at the cards before you buy. Don’t buy a card that announces a “Mass intention”; that is, if the card says something like “As a Christmas gift to you, the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass will be offered for you and your intentions during this Holy Season.” At that point, we’ve moved out the realm of Lutheranism and into the world of buying and selling masses to confer special benefits and graces. Not very Lutheran. Mass intention cards are also used for sympathy cards, Easter, and other special occasions.

easter novena

  • Of the sacramental-themed cards, the Baptism cards are most likely to be acceptable for Lutherans. Look for the ones, especially, that use the biblical language of baptismal regeneration and promise. The Catholic church has a very different concept of confirmation than Lutherans, regarding it as a sacrament with special grace imparted by the blessing of the bishop. Confirmation cards that feature the bishop’s mitre and crosier do not really resonate with North American Lutheranism at all. Again, if you’re not sure, stick with biblical themes in the card’s message. First Communion also tends to look different, culturally as well as theologically, between our two confessions. In the RCC, First Communion cards are geared towards 7-year-olds, and the theology of the Lord’s Supper is quite different. Also, remember that if you’re getting a card for a wedding, the RCC regards marriage as a sacrament, and a card may say something to that effect that a Lutheran would find questionable. Stuff to keep in mind.
  • Catholic stores have lots of inexpensive medals and charms featuring a wide range of personages and topics. Most will be saints. Some may have images relating to Baptism, the Lord’s Supper, the cross, etc. that you may find interesting. Look at the BACK of the medal before you buy it. If it’s a guardian angel pendant, does it say “Pray for us” on the back? Lutherans don’t ask departed saints or angels for their prayers. Only something relating to the Trinity can appropriately be paired with “Pray for us.” Also, look out for charms that have the promises of indulgences specifically attached to them. The whole Reformation began because of the problem of indulgences.

indulgence medal

  • If you’re interested in a statue of Jesus or one of the saints, you’ve got your work cut out for you. Most statues of Jesus and the saints are related to specific, mystical devotions based on visions that various saints are said to have had over the years. The Sacred Heart of Jesus, for example, is probably the most ubiquitous Jesus image available in statuary (and widespread in pictures), and even some Lutherans have used it. However, it is born out of the mystical visions of a 17th-century nun, in which Jesus gave certain promises about revering this image of his heart, including a promise relating to attending Friday mass for a certain number of months to receive special graces. Lutherans would be uncomfortable with the origins of this devotion. The image of Jesus giving a benediction with rays of white and red light coming from his chest is called the Divine Mercy, and it also is based on revelations of a nun. Young Jesus wearing pink with outstretched arms or holding a flaming heart is called Divino Niño, is also based on clerical mysticism, and miraculous powers are attributed to the image in popular Catholicism. And so on. Personally, I favor statues such as the Good Shepherd, the resurrected Christ, or a regular crucifix. These do not usually have popular, mystical devotions associated with them. Images of Mary are even more difficult to find. Most that you will find from a Catholic supplier are images like Our Lady of Grace (arms outstretched and downward, standing on a globe), OL of Lourdes (white robe, blue sash, praying hands with rosary), the Immaculate Heart (portrait of Mary pointing to a flaming heart crowned with flowers), and the like, all of which are attached to mystical apparitions or visions that include promises of favor and intercession when certain works or devotions are performed. If you want a picture or statue free from these associations, you’ll have to do your research on Marian iconography. Certain images of the Holy Family may be preferable, and they can be used for Christmas, too.


  • If you find anything with the Lord’s Prayer, it’s probably not going to include the “for thine is the kingdom” ending. That’s certainly not the end of the world, but just keep it in mind if someone is going to be using it for their prayers and wants to be consistent with what they’re saying in church.


Okay, there’s probably tons and tons more that could be said, but I think that’ll do for now. If you have any other observations or helpful suggestions for the readers out there, please add your comments with your experiences!


3 responses to “Helpful tips for Lutherans shopping at a Catholic gift shop

  1. Oh, a couple more things related to the Catechism: If you get something with the Ten Commandments on it, the last two commandments will be switched. 😮 And of course, you’ll get “Catholic” with a capital “C” in your Creed. By it they mean the Roman church; we don’t, which is why we usually lower-case the “C” (though it doesn’t really matter in the grand scheme of things if you know what you’re saying and why. It tends to confuse people, though).

    • I have enjoyed browsing around your beautiful blog and admiring all the beautiful artwork. And of course as a Catholic this post caught my eye, too. Regarding Mass cards–the Mass is not something you can sell, or exchange for any material good. I have never purchased Mass cards at a store, but in parishes, there is a suggested donation to have a Mass said someone. If you’re poor and cannot give the suggested amount, they can’t turn you away. It is like the way they do admission in a lot of nonprofit museums (such as the Metropolitan Museum of Art in NYC). There is a “suggested donation” of $20 for adults (or whatever) but you can give as much or as little as you like–or nothing. Most people do pay the suggested donation at such museums, because we know that the arts are important and it costs money to keep the lighting just right, and to control the humidity, and keep the museum running for future generations. At the same time, the works contained are priceless treasures and it would be wrong to deprive others of them simply because they can’t pay.

  2. Our Catholic bookstore, now Orthodox bookstore, in town has always had a supply of both Anglican and Lutheran books, including the Small Catechism, the Treasury of Daily Prayer, as well as books by the church Fathers like St. Athanasius’s “On the Incarnation.” So if you are discerning in books, you may find quite acceptable ones. They also have some nice music CDs. I also found some nice prints with the Lord’s prayer and the Nicene Creed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s